it is so okay to be sad but do not wallow in it, you will be okay. At its core, it teaches that there were different stages in the evolution of our universe: Cosmic-evolution. It is a very long sequence, written in code, that needs to be transcribed and translated before a cell can make the proteins that are essential for life. Scientists have proved one of Charles Darwinâs theories of evolution â survival of the fittest â for the first time. It's chewy, easy to digest and its even curved toward the face to make the whole process so much easier. WHAT DO YOU THINK? That he made the video without checking his facts in advance (which would have told him modern agricultural products are heavily modified by man) is unlikely to improve the credibility of his other arguments. 38 (6): 12-13. It comes with a protective, non-slip surface to hold, which is also biodegradable and sits "gracefully" over the human hand. The overemphasis of GMO banana and papaya over the corn, soybeans, cotton, and canola that make up more than 99 percent of GMO acres turns the real-world situation on its head. To people who argue Banana's as proof, would it not also prove evolution, as monkeys have the very same hands? People and critics who came to watch the debate left disappointed. Cultivated bananas are parthenocarpic, which makes them sterile and unable to produce viable seeds. So Dawkins' accusation of calling Comfort an "ignorant fool"—half of that just got confirmed by Ray Comfort himself. cultivation on Mabuyag Island, Torres Strait. Ray Comfort, a Christian creationist and televangelist, uses a banana to slap evolution in the face in an excerpt from his Way of The Master television show co-hosted by former child star Kirk Cameron. The average banana contains about 420 milligrams of potassium. All cells on Earth, from our white blood cells, to simple bacteria, to cells in the leaves of trees, are capable of reading any piece of DNA from any life form on Earth. analyzing the chromosome complements of some banana cultivars. Was Ray calling the Coke can the "Atheist Nightmare"? More information: Robert N. Williams et al, Multidisciplinary evidence for early banana (Musa cvs.) When Charles Darwin introduced the world to the concept of evolution, he had proof and evidence to support his hypothesis. Epidemics were previously reported in Uganda where BSV is currently endemic. , For those of you who can't see embedded YouTube, here is the link. Hovind was willing to offer $2,000 for proof that a dog and a banana have a common ancestor, but he backed out of this when it was required that the judges be unbiased (Kolosick n.d.). Wycombe result shows that Gary Rowett is changing the script when it comes to Millwall â Saturday was proof of the continued evolution of the Lions 20 October 2020 Sports Reporter 0 Comments BY DANIEL MARSH And they'd keep indefinitely without going bad or losing their vitamin content. In 2006, Christian activist Kirk Cameron starred in a propaganda video which includes, in part, a one-minute segment with Ray Comfort on how the banana is proof of God's existence. Bananas (Musa spp) are a tropical crop, and a staple in the wet tropic areas of Africa, the Americas, mainland and island Southeast Asia, South Asia, Melanesia, and the Pacific islands.Perhaps 87% of the total bananas consumed worldwide today are locally consumed; the rest is distributed outside of the wet tropical regions in which they are grown.  Another example is that until a few decades ago, the banana best known in the developed world was the Gros Michel variety (said to have been a bit tastier than the Cavendish we eat today). Tracing antiquity of banana cultivation in Papua New Guinea, http://thinking-critically.com/2010/07/17/kirk-cameron-ray-comfort-and-bananas/, National Geographic - Lack of Sex Life Threatens Banana Crops, The imminent death of the Cavendish banana and why it affects us all. Because, supposedly, the banana was proof of God's design. In contrast, the larynx in a chimp, for example, sits higher in the throat than in a human. Dawkins is not afraid of anything (. a man in a banana suit, with banana powers to bananaize his victims, thus causing them to be trapped in a banana suit and given the powers to bananaize others. Notice it has a point at the top for ease of entry. But they probably do in Venezuela. Either way looks rather bad for him. In fact, the very practice of this is evidence of evolution. YouTube Videos from Evidence for God from Science God and Science YouTube channel Evolution vs. Design. They share about 50% of their genes with a banana. Epidemics were previously reported in Uganda where BSV is currently endemic. Comfort offers up the 'ironclad argument' that bananas are proof of God's intelligent design of the natural world because "the banana and the hand are perfectly made, one for the other. Acts & Facts. And just occasionally they would reproduce sexually to help the plant breeders to overcome their genetic bottleneck. Now if you study a well-made banana, you'll find, on the far side, there are 3 ridges. Wrong again: the point was that Ray called the banana the "Atheist Nightmare." What comfort didn't realize is that the banana has in fact been designed, by us. Seriously, Kirk, the whole of creation testifies to the genius of God's creation. Ray Comfort's 2006 Hysterical Banana Argument Demonstrates What Creationists Mean By 'Proof', Thou Shalt Not Kill. Part of HuffPost Religion. Notice how gracefully it sits over the human hand. If evolution weren't true, there would be no reason to expect these signs of common descent. The Theory of Evolution by natural selection is one of the most successful scientific theories ever propounded. Also, there are people who just don't like eating bananas, and some who have potentially fatal allergic reactions to them. It has outward indicators of inward contents - green, too early - yellow, just right - black, too late. BEHOLD THE BANANA! Additionally, Dawkins would not be the "alien man"; he would more likely be the "Aliens are a much better possible explanation than your god, provided intelligent design is true" man. The wild banana, the predecessor of the cultivated fruit favourite, does reproduce sexually, pollinating their flowers in the usual way and having the botanical equivalent of sex. In fact, the banana as we know it is the result of careful artificial selection by humans over the course of many years. They knew while going in that they had no case at all, and took the opportunity to evangelize on live camera to the viewers. > > Well, it was the Forbidden Fruit that doomed humanity. de Langhe, Edmond & de Maret, Pierre (2004). That is Ray Comfort's God. In case you somehow missed it, hereâs another chance to see him in his supporting role in Ray Comfortâs famous âBanana videoâ. About.com Trees & Shrubs - Do Bananas Have Seeds? Thatâs 11 bananas. If the archaeological evidence has been correctly interpreted, the banana was first domesticated 8000 ybp, which would make it the earliest domesticated fruit, by several thousand years. We first discuss two kinds of 'evolution-proof' antibiotic. Human-Chimp Similarities: Common Ancestry or Flawed Research? 2009. The video exhibiting the banana's design characteristics was made by Ray Comfort and Kirk Cameron some time in the 2000s for their Way of the Master series - it's effectively been disowned by them since, so is hard to trace the actual original. In contrast, wild bananas are packed full of bullet-like seeds and contain very little edible fruit. So either he lied in this video back in 2009, or after all these years of criticism and mockery he's lying in 2017 in his new book (or has deluded himself into thinking he knew it all along). (2000) provided further proof for this by. A possible scenario for the evolution of Banana streak virus in banana. The Cavendish banana, the specific cultivar that Ray Comfort displays to the viewer, was selected to replace the Gros Michael because it was second-best. The infinite monkey theorem states that a monkey hitting keys at random on a typewriter keyboard for an infinite amount of time will almost surely type any given text, such as the complete works of William Shakespeare.In fact, the monkey would almost surely type every possible finite text an infinite number of times. The soft, yellow flesh of the edible varieties is the result of collective mutations cultivated thousands of years ago. Deoxyribonucleic acid is the blueprint for all inherited characteristics in living things. "Tracking the banana: its significance in early agriculture". OK, not so funny... rather scary, actually: Considerably funnier: Capyâs Twits. Behind the development of Bananatex is a collaboration of Swiss bag brand QWSTION, a Taiwanese yarn specialist and QWSTIONâs weaving partner based in Taipei, Taiwan.These three parties partnered up to engage in the intense development and production process behind the new fabric, united by the drive to make a positive impact on the planetâs future. There is a "pull tab" at the "top" for easy access. Adaptation. The theory of evolution predicts patterns of species not just over time in the fossil record, but also in the distribution of species today around Earthâthe study of which is called biogeography. Tomkins, J. The Origin of Life and Evidences of Evolution: 1. . It is curved towards the face for ease of consumption and does not squirt in one's face during the act. There are also very few ergonomic properties associated with these fruits, either with them being large and bulky or covered in spines—again, demonstrating the opposite of the simple "pull tab" Comfort is so proud of. An additional "apology" video was released by Ray Comfort. The early Spanish explorers introduced banana plants into America from Spain as a hardcore, large cooking banana, known as a Plantain banana. The pop-up question at the end of this level asks whether a banana is more closely related to a lemon or an onion. It would be restored by the development of antibiotics to which bacteria cannot evolve resistance. Behold, the atheists' nightmare. The banana was first domesticated around 8,000-9,000 years ago, somewhere in South and/or Southeast Asia, probably in today's Papua New Guinea (which, following Comfort's logic, means that it was intelligently designed by some god worshiped there rather than by the Judeo-Christian God). TV and film critic Troy Patterson quoted on the debate (emphasis added), "In Cameron's introductory remarks at the debate—which can be seen at something like its full and numbing length at abcnews.go.com—he coolly claimed that "the existence of God can be proven 100 percent, absolutely without the use of faith. In the Beginning: Compelling Evidence for Creation and the Flood, Adam and Evolution: A Scientific Critique of Neo-Darwinism, Darwinism Under The Microscope: How Recent Scientific Evidence Points To Divine Design, Evolution Under the Microscope: A Scientific Critique of the Theory of Evolution, Mind and Cosmos: Why the Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature Is Almost Certainly False, Rethinking Darwin: A Vedic Study of Darwinism and Intelligent Design, Seeking God in Science: An Atheist Defends Intelligent Design, The Darwin Myth: The Life and Lies of Charles Darwin, The Mystery of Life's Origin: Reassessing Current Theories, The Origin of Human Nature: A Zen Buddhist Looks at Evolution, The Wonders of Creation Reveal God's Glory, Model academic freedom statute on evolution, Text of Arkansas Balanced Treatment for Creation-Science and Evolution-Science Act, Text of the Louisiana Academic Freedom Act, Christian Apologetics and Research Ministry, Louisiana Baptist University and Seminary, Affirmations and Denials Essential to a Consistent Christian (Biblical) Worldview, Answers in Genesis-Creation Ministries International's Statement of Faith, Answers in Genesis Dawkins interview controversy, Atheists Outline Their Global Religious Agenda, https://rationalwiki.org/w/index.php?title=Banana_argument&oldid=2247482, Ray Comfort offered to debate atheist professor, The debate offer by Ray is a "clever" and immature tactic, often used by creationists. Health authorities recommend a daily allowance of 4,700 milligrams. There is little that is natural about the banana as we know it today. If bananas were truly "intelligently designed" they would have raisins in them. Stupid video about atheist rebuttal points. You'll find the maker of the banana, Almighty God, has made it with a non-slip surface. So, if bananas are really such perfect examples of God's handiwork, if they are such a perfect food for humans, then why do they only grow in the tropics where so many people have no easy access to them? BSV is a plant pararetrovirus of the family Caulimoviridae, gen â¦ Evolution is a process that results in heritable changes in population spread over many generations leading to diversity of organisms on earth. Evolution of the Banana Plant. The evolution process for the Flamingo is full of theories, questions, wholes, and pieces of evidence. This review of this "apology" video has already established that: Ray was ignorant of the evolutionary history of the banana, and is a fool for claiming God gave man the knowledge to modify dogs so they can fit in his car. So it is that the battle lines between TRUTH AND LIE, GOOD AND EVIL are being drawn around the banana. ;)----- One monkey said to another, "How are our relatives doing in civilization?" BSV is a plant pararetrovirus of the â¦ Similarly, God did the same with these ancient pre-Adam tribes: the knowledge to breed wild cats with the intention of making them the perfect size pet. Why? Big Bang Theory Darwin's Theory of Evolution Creation vs. Evolution Evidence for Evolution Evidence for Creation The Origin of Life The Complexity of Life Intelligent Design Back to FAQ. Musa consist of about 40 species and is distributed through India, New Guinea, Australia and Southeast Asia (Simmonds, 1962). In fact, some of us have probably been hearing it for the majority of our lives. According to Ray Comfort, the banana is "the atheist's nightmare", as he considers its ease of use, nutritional value and "colour-coding" to be irrefutable proof of intelligent design. Sign up for membership to become a founding member and help shape HuffPost's next chapter. The banana in the form that Comfort uses to illustrate his point is quite different from its wild predecessors — specifically, it's a seedless triploid, an asexual clone bred through banana-tree "pups" - manually-cut side-shoots of the parent corm, including a stem and some roots. ... D Hont et al. Is it proof of evolution when monkeys spit out banana seeds? In this case, Comfort selectively reports only the positive features of the banana, while other fruits have significant drawbacks that show anything but good design. tomorrow is a â¦ The durian fruit also possesses an incredibly pungent aroma that has seen the transport and storage of the fruit banned in some public places. Being the result of an evolution via Evolution stone, Arcanine is rarely found in the wild, but when found, it is usually seen living in prairies, ... as seen in The Pokémon Banana League (Part 1). You'll find a wrapper which is biodegradable, has perforations. As any sandwich connoisseur can tell you, banana goes great with that other atheist's nightmare. It isn't new. 4) Genetics. The banana (Musa acuminata) genome and the evolution of monocotyledonous plants. It went up against Satoshi's Charmeleon in PZ08 and lost. The early Spanish explorers introduced banana plants into America from Spain as a hardcore, large cooking banana, known as a Plantain banana. Also, Ray released his book on February 12, 2009. ©2020 Verizon Media. He waxes so rhapsodic about it that it could inspire any number of bad jokes about fruit fetishes and the like, but we would never ever condone that sort of behaviorexcept whenever you read this articleon this web site. Multidisciplinary evidence for early banana (Musa cvs.) You feel insulted and "dehumanized" when scientists say that people evolved from other life forms, but you have no problem with the Biblical claim that we were created from dirt. BEHOLD THE > BANANA! But the type of logic used when looking at specific design aspects of natural products can be used to prove the non-existence of a designer god too. The lack of sexual reproduction in cultivated bananas and plantains prevents genetic diversity, so cultivated bananas are vulnerable to a range of pests and diseases. Fossils provide solid evidence that organisms from the past are not the same as those found today, and fossils show a progression of evolution. Well, it was the Forbidden Fruit that doomed humanity. Banana, twinkie, I am sure that some of us have heard this before. The banana is shaped to fit into the human hand. Also most wolves and wild dogs can already fit into cars (with the exception of VW beetles) better than a great dane, and the ancestor of domestic cats is more or less the same size as all domestic cat breeds we have today. Professor Dawkins actually does have degrees and participates in scientific academia, the process of peer reviewing, and performs actual scientific studies. Modern bananas are sterile, containing only tiny residual seeds, so new banana plants are propagated from cuttings. Nature Ecology & Evolution , 2020; DOI: 10.1038/s41559-020-1278-3 Cite This Page : Today is National Voter Registration Day! Dr. Barend Vlaardingerbroek corresponded with Hovind concerning clarification of conditions and matters of fairness and got a runaround. The banana and the hand are perfectly made, one for the other. A good number of atheists in the West typically think that they have looked at the evidence and come to the conclusion that it is most reasonable not to believe that a god exists. Failures of Evolution: Speciation of Goatsbeard; Failures of Evolution: Ontogeny Recapitulates Phylogeny References. The fossils that we have found provide windows into the past and direct evidence of evolution. Or have vaccines in them for easier application and distribution or countless other attributes that have been pipe dreams of genetic engineers around the world for years. EVOLUTION." is grown during the last 20 years with no convincing evidence of epidemics. While the entire picture still is unknown, there is enough information out there for some realistic formations of their early life to come to light. To pretty much everyone that would be very good news. He tried to compare one thing that is naturally produced with something else that was mechanically formed—that was the comparison; he was not giving an example of two man-made things (even though the banana was bred by man). Yellow, just right. The banana was probably first domesticated in New Guinea, although if not there, it was definitely domesticated first in southeast Asia. But this selection has rendered the fruits of these plants completely sterile, and so unable to survive in a wild "natural" state.. In fact, early-stage human embryos have a tail and rudimentary gills like a fish. Ray and Kirk promised to prove God scientifically without the use of faith or the Bible, but they failed. 101 evidences for a young age of the Earth and the universe. Evolution- CBSE Notes for Class 12 Biology. Because islands provide isolated habitats where there is little chance of interbreeding with mainland species, evolutionary theory â¦ by Richard Peacock 1. And come in banoffee varieties. Poor subsistence farmers in the developing world can face starvation when their whole plantation crop suddenly dies. This page was last modified on 20 November 2020, at 14:45. Black, too late. [citation NOT needed] This is something a sane atheist would be happy to be wrong about. Designs in DNA; Epic Failures of Evolution Series. That is completely contradictory to what Ray said in his apology video, "My apologies for not explaining myself more clearly, I was not aware that the common banana had been so modified through hybridization." When opening the banana one must use the convenient pull tab to open it, and be careful that it doesn't spurt in your face and leave a sticky mess. For those who are not aware of the significance of that date, February 12 is. Some scientists believe that the latest disease threat to the industry from Fusarium TR4 is caused by a failure to manage soil properly.